Not all Tippet Materials are Created Equal

May 07, 2012

We knew Stroft was good, but just how good didn't become apparent until we compared it with other well known tippet materials.
This is a very simple direct comparison, we've graphed common Monofilaments and one Fluorocarbon material that is reputedly very strong (Which it is, but not as strong as Stroft Mono')
We have also compared Stroft GTM against the top Fluorocarbons from these manufacturers. In all cases Stroft GTM and ABR came out on top.  
Just the Facts:
Results are graphed from actual specifications and values printed by the various manufacturers and converted into metrics.
(Click to expand)


Stroft-gtm-chartlg
Observations / Findings:
  • Umpqua.  The results are very interesting. Notice how the graphed results from 6X up show as a perfectly straight line.  Stated diameters and breaking strength increase in a directly proportional manner - unlike any other manufacturer. 
    Umpqua either have the most perfect, precise manufacturing method in the world - or their labelling is simply increased in perfect increments regardless of actual material strength.  You decide.
  • Maxima. All Maxima Monofilaments showed very similar results. Some anglers believe that this material is actually underrated. Our simple comparison does not test actual against stated ratings (But we will do this in the future) Regardless, Maxima was at the bottom of our list, and even if it was underrated by as much as 30% it would still not feature in the top 3 materials.

 

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in The Drift - Fly Fishing, Fly Casting and Fly Rod Building

Epic fly rod building kit
Win an Epic Fly Rod Building Kit

May 20, 2022

Win and build your very own Epic fly rod!

Together with The Fly Fishing Nation we are giving away 2 X Epic Ready To Wrap Fly Rod Building kits to two of you glorious souls out there.

Read More
Winter Fly Fishing In New Zealand
Winter Fly Fishing With Brian O'Keefe

February 25, 2022

I was recently chatting to my buddy Brian O'Keefe about what he was up to over the winter months, and after having returned home from a balmy trip to Patagonia he was straight back into it - in the snow.
In New Zealand, all but the most hardened anglers hang up their gear come winter, so I had a few questions.
Read More
Fly Rod Building videos and resources instructions for building a fly rod with our fly rod building kits
Fly Rod Building Resource Page

February 14, 2022

Join our Epic Fly Rod Building Kit Forum on Facebook here. This group is specifically for building Epic Ready To Wrap Fly Rod Kits - Please note: it is not a general fly rod building group

Read More